How corrosive is softened water?
CORROSION IN SOFTENED WATER
Disadvantages of home water softening
The corroded metal from the pipes can end up in your water. This can contribute to elevated lead and copper levels in drinking water. Potential health effects from additional sodium.
pH Levels: Softened water generally has a slightly elevated pH level due to the presence of sodium ions. This mildly alkaline will actually lessen corrosion to some extent as it creates a protective layer on the metal surfaces, hindering the progression of corrosion.
Softened water may contain metals because water is a universal solvent. When water is heated or softened, it is more prone to leach metals from water pipes and other parts of the indoor plumbing system. Copper in pipes, lead in soldered joints, and metal faucets are especially vulnerable to heated or softened water.
This type of water can affect how long your metal pipes will last and how fast the pipes will corrode. Water that is soft will not create mineral build up within the pipes but it can create pinhole leaks as soft water is lacking in minerals making it aggressive towards unlined metal (copper) pipes.
Cons of Soft Water
Regularly drinking soft water increases a person's sodium levels, which can lead to multiple health problems including blood pressure. The process used to make the water soft also makes it more volatile, which means it picks up more unwanted elements from your pipes.
The process of water softening can cause water to have an elevated amount of sodium. While most soft water is perfectly safe to drink, elevated sodium levels may not be ideal for people with high blood pressure. But even for those with health concerns, there is a way to make softened water drinkable.
There is nothing to be concerned about the corrosion of your aluminium heat exchanger if your central heating boiler has been filled with softened water. Worcester Bosch, after 18 years, has never been able to show the industry a heat exchanger corroded by softened water.
Naturally soft water is corrosive as it has a low pH and low TDS; however, cation-exchange water softening does not contribute to any factors that accelerate corrosion. Also, there is a lack of scientific evidence supporting the claim that hard-water scale is an effective form of corrosion control.
Summary. The difference in hard water and soft water is the amount of sodium within it. Soft water is safe to drink as the amount of sodium added is very small.
Why is soft water a problem for plumbers?
While soft water bypasses the main problem hard water has with pipes, soft water has its own problem in the form of corrosion. Soft water is able to dissolve metals such as cadmium and lead - metals that can be toxic if dissolved into the water that is then ingested.
Naturally soft water, on the other hand, contains very little dissolved solids; its pH is often low and buffering capacity is negligible. Hence, naturally soft water is often very corrosive to metals.
Study by the Gas Institute
Another study, conducted by the Gas Institute, found that softened water accelerates the depletion of anode rods in water heaters. Anode rods ordinarily keep heater tanks from rusting for five years. When the life of an anode is shortened, the life of the heater is as well.
CORROSION IN SOFTENED WATER
The removal of hardness with an ion exchange water softener does not affect the factors which cause or accelerate corro- sion. Softening does not change the pH or carbon dioxide concentration, the dissolved oxygen concentration, or the total chemical concentration of minerals.
Reverse osmosis is a highly effective and natural method for removing sodium from softened water. At the same time, reverse osmosis systems also dramatically reduce the number of contaminants in water. Reverse osmosis systems are effective at removing or reducing: Sodium.
Water softeners can contribute to corrosion. Saline and hydrogen peroxide applied to metal causes a rusty surface sometimes valued as a patina to make the new metal into aged-looking pieces of art. That may be desirable if you want to put a patina on a metal object as a garden feature or a work of art.
- Considerable Upfront Costs and Maintenance Costs. As we mentioned earlier, water softeners are an investment. ...
- Some Are Linked to Health Risks. ...
- Some People Prefer the Taste and Health Benefits of Hard Water. ...
- Some Types of Water Softeners Waste More Water.
The flavor of hard water is often preferred to that of soft water as well. Though soft water is safe to drink in most cases, it often has a salty taste depending on the softening method used, and is sometimes not suitable for drinking as it is lacking in minerals and may have added salts or solvents.
Cons of Installing a Water Softener
Subjectively, soft water doesn't taste as good as hard water and doesn't provide the calcium ions that some need in their drinking water for stronger teeth and bones. A water softener is not a substitute for a home filtration system as it doesn't remove lead or other heavy metals.
For most healthy people, the amount of added sodium in the softened water poses no health problems. However, for people who are hypertensive (have high blood pressure) and must live on a low-sodium diet or a sodium-restricted diet, the sodium in the softened water can be hazardous to people's health.
Does Brita filter remove sodium from softened?
Can a Brita Filter Remove Salt? There is no evidence that a Brita filter can remove salt from your water. Perhaps more research is required, but at this time, the Brita filters on sale don't make this claim, and there don't seem to be any future plans to release a filter with this capability.
Soft Water in your Pipe System
Water that is soft will not create mineral build up within the pipes but it can create pinhole leaks as soft water is lacking in minerals making it aggressive towards unlined metal (copper) pipes.
The degradation of the galvanized piping in a soft water system can occur in a short period of time, and problems can arise in as few as two to five years after a new installation (Figure 1).
Seawater is normally more corrosive than fresh water because of the higher conductivity and the penetrating power of the chloride ion through surface films on a metal. The rate of corrosion is controlled by the chloride content, oxygen availability, and the temperature.
Soft water that contains sodium salts does not coat the pipes and consequently is more corrosive. Water that is moderately alkaline (40 to 70 mg/L) with a pH between 7.0 and 8.2 is usually not corrosive. Water with a pH below 6.5 will be corrosive, especially if alkalinity also is low.
References
- https://www.tunnelvision.com.au/blog/hard-water-vs-soft-water/
- https://www.raynewater.com/blog/how-to-remove-salt-from-water/
- https://www.casemed.com/index.php/resources/blog/item/41-the-problem-with-water-softeners
- https://www.freedrinkingwater.com/water-news/news1/1-08-traditional-salt-based-water-softening-environment-impact.htm
- https://nelsonwater.com/blog/can-brita-filter-remove-softened-water-salt/
- https://www.hydroworks.co.uk/169/Can-you-put-softened-water-into-a-boiler
- https://clearwaterarizona.com/blog/how-to-make-softened-water-drinkable/
- https://www.freedrinkingwater.com/water-education/quality-water-hard.htm
- https://mmengineering.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Conduit-Vol.-12-No.-3.pdf
- https://www.watersoftenersinfo.co.uk/post/is-softened-water-corrosive
- https://mooreheating.com/pros-and-cons-of-a-water-softener/
- https://www.freedrinkingwater.com/water_health/health3/water-softeners-and-health.htm
- https://wqa.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/article-4-Corosion-and-Soft-water-Vol-V.pdf
- https://curaflo.com/soft-water/
- https://www.health.state.mn.us/communities/environment/water/factsheet/softening.html
- https://wcponline.com/2019/03/15/water-softeners-and-corrosion/
- https://corrosion-doctors.org/Corrosion-by-Water/Types-of-water.htm
- https://www.americanwaterheater.com/media/22693/ta_1041.pdf
- https://www.aquatell.ca/blogs/aquatell/are-water-softeners-bad-for-copper-pipes
- https://twon.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2021/06/drinking-water-problems-corrosion.pdf
- https://www.plumbwize.ca/blog/water-softener-advantages-and-disadvantages/
- https://www.ecowater-softeners.co.uk/for-your-family/drinking-softened-water/
- https://www.ukwta.org/assets/NewFolder/Softened-water-is-not-more-corrosive-Rev2-1.pdf
- https://villageplumbing.com/blog/pros-and-cons-of-having-a-water-softener/